Compliance / Cyber insurance

    Your cyber-insurance renewal wants a pen test.

    Get the evidence underwriters now expect, on their timeline. A recent third-party pen test is increasingly the difference between a renewal quote and a declination — and can help you qualify for better coverage and terms.
    Policy yearIndependent testMonth 9 · datedQuestionnaireMonth 8BindRenewalThird-party, attributableRetest included

    The honest requirement

    Underwriters don't legally require a pen test — but their questionnaire does.

    No cyber-insurance carrier requires a penetration test by contract for every policyholder. Small policies still bind on the security questionnaire alone. So the honest answer is: it isn't mandatory.

    In practice: renewal applications from Coalition, Chubb, AXA, Beazley, Travelers, and most of the mid-market carriers now ask whether you've had an independent penetration test in the last 12 months. Answering "no" moves your file into a higher-scrutiny lane, can trigger sub-limits on ransomware and business-interruption cover, and — for organizations above roughly $25M revenue — can result in outright non-renewal. Applicants who present a current pen-test report bundled with MFA and EDR are better positioned to qualify for better coverage and terms at renewal.

    What auditors accept

    Evidence, in the format your assessor already uses.

    • Executive summary sized for an underwriting file (2–3 pages)

    • Signed report on firm letterhead with engagement dates

    • Severity-ranked findings with clear remediation status

    • Remediation letter for critical and high findings

    • Retest letter confirming closure — the artifact carriers reward

    • Attestation your broker can attach to the renewal submission

    Engagement mapping

    The D1–D9 engagement, mapped to Cyber insurance evidence.

    Cyber insurance evidence timeline

    Testing window

    1. D1

      Recon & scoping with your broker's questionnaire in hand.

    2. D2–3

      External attack-surface enumeration.

    3. D4–6

      Exploit reasoning against exposed services and web apps.

    4. D7–8

      Controlled PoC on critical exposures.

    5. D9

      Reporting, remediation plan, broker-ready summary.

    D1
    Scope aligned to the surfaces the carrier asked about.Recon & scoping with your broker's questionnaire in hand.
    D2–3
    Perimeter inventory matching the domains listed on your application.External attack-surface enumeration.
    D4–6
    Findings register with underwriter-facing risk framing.Exploit reasoning against exposed services and web apps.
    D7–8
    Proof-of-exploit evidence that survives an underwriter's technical review.Controlled PoC on critical exposures.
    D9
    Signed report + 2-page executive summary your broker can submit as-is.Reporting, remediation plan, broker-ready summary.

    Cyber insurance FAQ

    Frequently asked.

    No carrier requires a pen test contractually across every policy. But most 2026 renewal questionnaires ask whether you've had an independent test in the last 12 months, and answering 'no' can trigger sub-limits, higher premiums, or non-renewal — especially above roughly $25M revenue. A current report is the single fastest way to move your file into the preferred underwriting lane.

    Underwriters want a signed report on the pen-testing firm's letterhead, engagement dates and scope, severity-ranked findings, and — most importantly — a remediation or retest letter confirming criticals and highs are closed. We ship a 2–3 page executive summary formatted specifically for the underwriting file, alongside the full technical report.

    Most carriers treat a pen test as current for 12 months from the report date. If your renewal is more than 12 months out, plan the test to complete within 90 days of the submission window so critical findings have time to be remediated and retested before the underwriter sees the file.

    Evidence by framework

    Same engagement. Different paperwork.

    Underwriters price the renewal on remediation evidence, not on the scan count.

    Underwriter-ready · dated evidence of control testing

    Next step

    Scope a Cyber insurance pen test.

    Thirty-minute scoping call. Fixed-scope quote within one business day. Report and evidence bundle ready for your auditor.

    Request a pen test scope call →